Logo_EMN_dark-02
Logo_EMN_dark-02
Logo_EMN_dark-02
Logo_EMN_dark-02

Eisenhower Media Network

Logo_EMN_dark-02

Eisenhower Media Network

  • About EMN
  • Experts
  • Media
  • Reports
  • Contact An Expert
  • Donate
Recent Posts
  • Matthew Hoh: Veterans for Peace with Matthew Hoh and Mike Ferner
  • Matthew Hoh: Russian mercenary chief threatens to withdraw from Bakhmut
  • William Astore: Are the Best Years of My Country Behind Me?

One day, a village of roughly 1200 people in South Vietnam ceased to exist. The U.S. Air Force destroyed it, and the report read “Target 100% destroyed, body-count 1200 KBA (killed by air) confirmed.”

It wasn’t an “enemy” village. It was a village that had failed to pay its taxes to a South Vietnamese provincial commander, a lieutenant colonel and ostensibly a U.S. ally. He wanted the village destroyed to set an example to other recalcitrant villages, and the U.S. Air Force did what it does: It put bombs and napalm on target.

At Seventh Air Force headquarters, the brass knew this village’s “crime.” As a brigadier general said to then-Lieutenant Colonel James Robert “Cotton” Hildreth, “Damn, Cotton, don’t you know what’s going on? That village didn’t pay their taxes. That [South Vietnamese] lieutenant colonel … is teaching them a lesson.”

It’s a “lesson” that made Cotton Hildreth, who later became a major general, “really sick” and “very bitter” about his role as a combat pilot in the Vietnam War. Later, in an oral interview, he admitted “I don’t talk about this [the war] very much.” One can understand why.

At the time, Hildreth brought his concerns to General William Momyer, the Seventh Air Force Commander, but Momyer offered only platitudes, saying that Hildreth was “doing some good, somewhere,” by dropping bombs and napalm and other ordnance on Vietnam and the Vietnamese people.

We know this story only because Cotton Hildreth was willing to share it after being retired from the Air Force for fifteen years. A few days before this village was obliterated, Hildreth and his wingman, flying A-1 Skyraiders, had been ordered to destroy the village with napalm. They refused to do so after making low and slow passes over the village, only to be greeted by children waving their arms in friendship. In “The Wingman and the Village,” Hugh Turley’s article about this in the Hyattsville Life & Times (July 2010), Hildreth admitted his wingman had dropped napalm away from the village first, and Hildreth then did the same. The wingman in question, old for a pilot at age 48 and a grandfather, had seen a woman running with two children from her hut. He’d made a snap decision to disobey orders.

As the wingman told Hildreth when they returned to base: “Sir, I have three small grandchildren at home, and I could never face them again if I had followed those orders.” The unnamed wingman was later reassigned to a non-combat role.

When Hildreth was asked later if he’d have destroyed the village if he’d been flying an F-105 “Thud,” which flew higher and much faster than the A-1 Skyraider, he admitted he likely would have, because “you don’t see the people.”

What can we learn from this story? This atrocity? That it’s very easy to kill when you never see the people being killed. That it’s easy to follow orders and much harder to disobey them. That the Air Force brass at headquarters knew they were complicit in mass murder but that it meant more to them to keep one South Vietnamese provincial commander happy than it meant to keep 1200 innocent people alive.

Read the full article here. 

What can we learn from this story? This atrocity? That it’s very easy to kill when you never see the people being killed.

William Astore

Previous PostWilliam Astore: Reinventing the US Military for Real National Defense
Next PostDanny Sjursen: A Life and Nation Transformed: 20 Years On From West Point’s Gates and the War on Terror

Latest Posts

News-item_Astore-1

William Astore: Are the Best Years of My Country Behind Me?

It was, of course, not to be and today we once again find ourselves on an increasingly apocalyptic pla

Astore, Bracing Views
May 10, 2023
News-item_Astore-1

William Astore: Learning Nothing from Iraq War

What has America learned from the colossal failure of the Iraq War? Not what it should have learned, n

Astore, LA Progressive
February 17, 2023
News-item_Astore-1

William Astore: Blinken braves bilateral deep-freeze in Beijing

Below is an excerpt from this Politico newsletter on China that features a quote from EMN Senior Fello

Astore, Politico
February 3, 2023
Recent
Matthew Hoh: Veterans for Peace with Matthew Hoh and Mike Ferner
Hoh, Veterans for Peace
May 23, 2023
Matthew Hoh: Russian mercenary chief threatens to withdraw from Bakhmut
Hoh, The Hill
May 11, 2023
William Astore: Are the Best Years of My Country Behind Me?
Astore, Bracing Views
May 10, 2023
Twitter Feed
Missing Consumer Key - Check Settings
Tags
9/11 (7) Afghanistan (7) Afghanistan war (8) Afghanistan withdrawal (18) Air Force (4) Biden (4) China (12) Cold War (4) Danny Sjursen (13) defense budget (11) Dennis Fritz (9) Dennis Laich (4) department of defense (5) Eisenhower (7) Erik Edstrom (5) featured (60) forever wars (7) Gregory Daddis (14) Iraq (26) Iraq War (19) Lawrence Wilkerson (8) Matthew Hoh (31) memorial (4) military (15) military industrial complex (28) monument (6) NDAA (4) news (152) nuclear war (4) Pentagon (26) podcast (9) radio (10) refugees (4) Rivers of Babylon (5) Russia (22) terrorism (4) Ukraine (21) United States (67) veterans (22) veterans day (6) Vietnam War (5) war (29) Washington D.C. (4) whistleblower (4) William Astore (46)
© 2022 Eisenhower Media Network. All Rights Reserved